Shohei Ohtani (大谷翔平) or Aaron Judge for AL MVP? Verlander breaks down AL MVP race | Flippin’ Bats │ 人気野球選手-youtebe動画リンクまとめ

【視聴数　4194】

【チャンネル名　Flippin’ Bats with Ben Verlander】

【タグ　Flippin’ Bats,Flippin Bats,Flippin’ Bats fox sports,Flippin’ Bats with Ben Verlander,Ben Verlander,MLB,baseball,Shohei Ohtani,大谷翔平,Aaron Judge,Shohei Ohtani vs Aaron Judge,AL MVP race,AL MVP,mlb baseball show,mlb baseball news,mlb baseball updates,american league,Los Angeles Angels,New York Yankees】

コメント（46件）

erivers71 より:

9月 17, 2022 2:04 am

1000% agreed.

返信
Robert Gunner より:

9月 17, 2022 3:56 am

Yordan Alvarez for AL MVP

返信
川島大地より:

9月 17, 2022 8:39 am

One thing I can say that even if judge played for the angels with ohtani and trout the angels would still be a terrible team and the Yankees would be a strong team

返信
koro_ より:

9月 17, 2022 10:34 am

Shohei’s strikeout rate is currently “12.00”. Historically speaking, there have been 18 pitchers who have reached this level of strikeout rate after exceeding the prescribed number of innings pitched. Even N. Ryan, the all-time strikeout king, could not do it. Will he be able to clear this mark in his remaining appearances? If he exceeds the prescribed number of pitches and at bats, achieves double-digit wins and double-digit home runs, and achieves a strikeout rate of 12.00, there will be no other word than “MVP.

返信
Genji Sanada より:

9月 17, 2022 12:23 pm

⚠️WAR Deficiencies❗️Pass it on‼️

Although Judge leads Ohtani in WAR at this time, that metric does not capture the full value of the true “Shohei Ohtani = two-way player”. Ohtani’s WAR is simply the sum of his WAR as a fielder and his WAR as a pitcher.

『WAR as a fielder』
Judge outperforms Ohtani in hitting and is ahead of him in “WAR as a fielder” because he plays both center fielder and right fielder and plays average level defense.
Since WAR is a measure of how much a player contributes to wins compared to “replaceable players” at that position, Judge’s comparison is to a “replaceable level” center fielder or right fielder, whereas Ohtani’s comparison is to a “replaceable level” DH.
If there is a “replaceable level” DH who hits a home run the day after pitching, please let me know.😉

In order to make players at different positions comparable, WAR is corrected by position, with catchers and rangers receiving a positive rating based on their defensive contributions, and first basemen and DHs receiving a negative rating.
In other words, the difference in “WAR as a fielder” between Judge and Ohtani is not so much the difference in hitting performance, but rather the fact that Judge is playing center, while the two-way Ohtani has the exact same negative assessment as a “replacement level” DH.

『WAR as a pitcher』
On the other hand, Judge’s “WAR as a pitcher” for not pitching is “0”.
Ohtani’s time on the mound is much more “valuable” than Judge’s time in the outfield, but that does not mean that Judge receives a negative value in terms of “WAR as a pitcher.
This discrepancy proves that the WAR metric is not structured to capture the full value of “Shohei Ohtani = two-way player,” and is the primary reason for the difference with Judge.

返信
Chim Samnang より:

9月 17, 2022 2:21 pm

Shohei is the MVP 🎉🎉🎉🎉

返信